Josh's Frogs vs Josh's Frogs
Head-to-head comparison of Josh's Frogs Dubia Roaches and Josh's Frogs Black Soldier Fly Larvae. See specs, pros, cons, and our verdict.
Quick Winner
Josh's Frogs Dubia Roaches
Josh's Frogs Dubia Roaches earns our top recommendation for most keepers. Josh's Frogs Black Soldier Fly Larvae delivers solid performance at a lower price point.
Full VerdictPros & Cons
AJosh's Frogs Dubia
Pros
- Cannot bite or stress gecko — safe to leave briefly in enclosure
- Higher Ca:P ratio than crickets (0.3:1 vs 0.13:1)
- Soft-bodied and easy to digest for adults and juveniles
- Josh's Frogs live delivery guarantee and consistent quality
Cons
- Illegal to keep in some US states (Florida, Hawaii) — check local laws
- Still require calcium dusting before each feeding
- More expensive per insect than crickets
BJosh's Frogs Black
Pros
- Only common feeder with naturally balanced Ca:P — no calcium dusting needed
- Affordable and widely available from Josh's Frogs
- Soft-bodied and wriggle actively — triggers feeding response
- High in lauric acid (antimicrobial fatty acid)
Cons
- Deficient in fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, K) when used long-term alone
- Must be rotated with other insects — not suitable as a sole feeder
- Short shelf life compared to roaches — use quickly after delivery
The Bottom Line
Josh's Frogs Dubia Roaches earns our top recommendation for most keepers. Josh's Frogs Black Soldier Fly Larvae delivers solid performance at a lower price point.
AChoose Josh's Frogs Dubia if...
All gargoyle geckos — best combination of nutrition, safety, and ease of use
BChoose Josh's Frogs Black if...
Budget-conscious keepers rotating multiple feeder types — removes need for calcium dusting
Want more options?
See all our picks in Best Feeder Insects for Gargoyle Geckos: 6 Picks That Work
Common Questions
Josh's Frogs Dubia Roaches (Best Overall) is best for All gargoyle geckos — best combination of nutrition, safety, and ease of use. Josh's Frogs Black Soldier Fly Larvae (Best Value) is best for Budget-conscious keepers rotating multiple feeder types — removes need for calcium dusting.
References & Sources
- https://joshsfrogs.com/care-sheet/gargoyle-gecko-care-sheet?srsltid
- https://reptifiles.com/heterodon-hognose-snake-care/hognose-substrate/
- https://reptifiles.com/mourning-gecko-care/mourning-gecko-substrate/
- https://reptifiles.com/african-fat-tailed-gecko-care-sheet/
- https://reptifiles.com/viper-gecko-care-sheet/
- https://reptifiles.com/chahoua-gecko-care-sheet/