Best Turtles to Have as Pets: 10 Top Choices for Keepers

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you.

Turtles are some of the most fascinating creatures on the planet. With their ancient lineage and unique charm, it's no wonder so many people are drawn to keeping them as pets. They offer a different kind of companionship—a quiet, observant presence that can last for decades. But choosing the right turtle is one of the most important decisions you'll make as a keeper.

Not all turtles are created equal when it comes to life in captivity. Some stay small and are relatively easy to care for, while others grow into giants that require pond-sized enclosures. This guide will walk you through the best turtles to have as pets, helping you find the perfect shelled friend for your experience level, budget, and living space.

Before You Dive In: Key Turtle Care Considerations

Bringing a turtle home is a major commitment, far greater than many first-time owners realize. Before you fall in love with a tiny, quarter-sized hatchling, you need to understand the realities of their long-term care.

Lifespan: A Decades-Long Friend

This isn't a two-year commitment like a hamster. Most popular pet turtles live for 20 to 50 years, and some can live even longer. The turtle you buy today could easily be with you through multiple moves, career changes, and life stages. Are you prepared to provide consistent care for that long?

Habitat Size & Cost

A tiny 10-gallon tank might house a baby turtle for a few months, but it will quickly need an upgrade. A good rule of thumb is to provide at least 10 gallons of water volume for every inch of shell length. A common 8-inch turtle needs an 80-gallon tank or larger, which is a significant investment in space and money. A full setup with a large tank, stand, filter, heater, and lighting can easily cost over $500.

Filtration is Non-Negotiable

Turtles are messy. They eat, sleep, and create waste in their water. Without powerful filtration, their enclosure will quickly become a toxic environment. You'll need a canister filter rated for at least twice the volume of your tank to keep the water clean and your turtle healthy. Even with a great filter, regular water changes are a must.

Essential Lighting and Heat

As reptiles, turtles are ectothermic, meaning they rely on their environment to regulate their body temperature. You must provide a warm basking area where they can get completely dry and soak up heat. This requires a dedicated heat lamp. More importantly, most species need a special UVB light to process calcium and prevent serious health issues like Metabolic Bone Disease (MBD). If you're looking for the right lamp, our guide to the Best Heat Lamps For Reptiles Comparison can help you choose.

The "4-Inch Law"

In the United States, it is illegal for any person or store to sell a turtle with a shell less than four inches long. This law was enacted in 1975 to curb Salmonella outbreaks in children, who were more likely to put small turtles in their mouths. While you can still acquire smaller turtles from breeders for educational or scientific purposes, the vast majority sold in pet stores must be over this size limit. This is a good thing—it gives you a better idea of the turtle's adult potential and discourages impulse buys.

The 10 Best Pet Turtles for Every Keeper

Now that you know what you're getting into, let's explore some of the best species for home keeping. We've ranked them based on size, hardiness, and overall suitability for new and intermediate keepers.

1. Common Musk Turtle (Stinkpot)

Often called a "Stinkpot," this turtle gets its name from the musky odor it can release when threatened, though this is rare in captivity. Don't let the name fool you; this is arguably the best pet turtle for beginners. Their small size is their biggest advantage. A single adult can live comfortably in a 20 to 40-gallon aquarium, making them suitable for apartment dwellers.

These turtles are primarily aquatic and are clumsy swimmers, preferring to walk along the bottom of the tank. They don't need exceptionally deep water. Their diet is easy to manage, consisting mainly of quality turtle pellets like Zoo Med Aquatic Turtle Food, insects, and worms. While they don't bask as frequently as other species, a basking spot is still required.

2. Reeve's Turtle

Reeve's Turtles are another fantastic small species that make wonderful pets. They are known for having more outgoing personalities than many other turtles and often become quite tame with gentle handling. Their manageable size means a 40-gallon tank is a good permanent home for an adult.

They are semi-aquatic and enjoy both a spacious swimming area and a dry basking dock. Like most turtles, they require clean, filtered water and proper UVB/heat lighting. Their personable nature and hardiness make them a rewarding choice for those new to the hobby who want a more interactive pet.

3. Western Painted Turtle

As one of North America's most widespread native turtles, the Painted Turtle is a classic beauty. The Western subspecies is particularly striking with its bright red and yellow markings on its plastron (bottom shell). They are active swimmers and dedicated baskers, making for a very display-worthy pet.

Because they are a bit larger, especially the females which can reach 10 inches, they need a bigger enclosure. Plan for at least a 75-gallon tank for a single adult. They are hardy and generally healthy when provided with proper care, including a varied diet and excellent water quality. Their active nature is a joy to watch.

4. Mississippi Map Turtle

Map Turtles get their name from the intricate, map-like lines on their shells. They are energetic and love to swim, so they appreciate a large, open tank with plenty of water. A prominent basking area is crucial, as they spend a good portion of their day basking under their heat and UVB lamps.

Map turtles can be more sensitive to poor water quality than other species, so a top-notch filter is essential. They can also be quite skittish, so they are better for owners who prefer to watch rather than handle their pets. Males stay significantly smaller than females, so choosing a male is a good way to keep the required tank size more manageable (e.g., a 40-55 gallon for a male vs. 90+ for a female).

5. African Sideneck Turtle

These turtles have a unique look, with long necks that they tuck to the side rather than pulling straight back into their shell. They are fully aquatic, so your focus will be on providing a great water environment. They aren't strong baskers and spend most of their time in the water.

An adult will need a 75-gallon tank or larger. One key difference is their sensitivity to cooler temperatures; their water needs to be kept consistently warm, usually between 75-80°F, using a submersible aquarium heater. Their unique appearance and gentle nature make them a popular choice.

6. Yellow-Bellied Slider

The Yellow-Bellied Slider is a common pet store turtle, known for the distinct yellow pattern on its plastron. They are active, love to bask, and have voracious appetites. While hardy, their large adult size is a serious consideration. A female can reach over a foot in length and will require a 125-gallon tank or even a small indoor pond.

Their care is straightforward—strong filtration, standard heating and UVB, and a varied diet—but the scale of it is what lands them in the intermediate category. You must be prepared to house a very large turtle for a very long time.

7. Red-Eared Slider

No list of pet turtles is complete without the Red-Eared Slider (RES). It is perhaps the most recognizable turtle in the world. Unfortunately, it's also one of the most frequently abandoned pets. People buy them as tiny, cute hatchlings and are completely unprepared when they grow into a large, demanding adult.

Their care is identical to the Yellow-Bellied Slider, but they can have a more aggressive, territorial personality. Because they are so over-bred and are an invasive species in many parts of the world, we strongly encourage you to adopt one from a reptile rescue rather than buying one from a store. If you have the space and resources, giving an adult RES a second chance can be incredibly rewarding.

8. Spotted Turtle

These are stunning little turtles, with a black shell covered in bright yellow spots. Their small size is appealing, but they are not a beginner pet. They are a semi-aquatic species that requires a unique habitat setup—often called a paludarium—with both a significant land area and a shallow water area. They are also more sensitive to water parameters and stress.

Furthermore, Spotted Turtles are a protected species in many parts of their native range. You must ensure you are buying a captive-bred specimen from a reputable breeder. Due to their specific needs and conservation status, they are best for experienced keepers.

9. Eastern Box Turtle

Now we move from the aquarium to the terrarium. Box Turtles are terrestrial, meaning they live on land. Their care is more similar to that of a tortoise. They need a large, humid enclosure with several inches of substrate for burrowing, like cypress mulch or coconut fiber. Outdoor pens in safe, temperate climates are ideal.

Box Turtles have a hinged shell that allows them to completely close up, which is a fascinating defense mechanism. Their diet is omnivorous, including insects, worms, leafy greens, and fruit. Their long lifespan and specific humidity needs make them a better fit for a dedicated keeper. Exploring their care could be a great next step after mastering some of the Best Pet Lizards for Beginners: 11 Species Ranked, as some habitat principles overlap.

10. Russian Tortoise

While not technically a turtle, tortoises are often what people mean when they search for the best land turtles for pets. The Russian Tortoise is one of the most popular and available species. They are small for a tortoise, but incredibly active and love to dig and climb, so they need a very secure, large enclosure—a "tortoise table" or, ideally, a safe outdoor pen.

They are herbivores and require a diet high in fiber and calcium, consisting of broadleaf weeds and greens. They do not eat fruit or protein. Because they don't need a water setup, some find their daily maintenance easier than an aquatic turtle's, but their need for space is just as significant.

Your New Shelled Companion

Choosing a pet turtle is an exciting journey, but it's one that demands thoughtful research. The most important step is to honestly assess your ability to meet the needs of a specific species for its entire, very long life. A small Musk Turtle has vastly different requirements from a large Slider or a terrestrial Box Turtle.

By prioritizing the animal's welfare and choosing a species that fits your lifestyle, you're setting yourself up for decades of rewarding companionship. Watching your turtle thrive in a beautiful habitat you've created is one of the great joys of reptile keeping. Do your homework, prepare their home in advance, and you'll have a healthy and happy pet for years to come.