Best Pet Turtles to Have: 10 Great Choices for Keepers

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you.

Turtles are some of the most fascinating and ancient reptiles you can keep. With their unique shells and deliberate movements, they bring a piece of the prehistoric world right into your home. But choosing a turtle isn't a decision to take lightly. These creatures can live for decades, and their care requirements are much more complex than just a bowl of water and some lettuce.

Finding the best pet turtles to have means matching a species' specific needs with your ability to provide for them for their entire lives. It's a huge commitment, but for the right person, it's an incredibly rewarding journey. Whether you're a seasoned keeper or just starting, this guide will walk you through our top 10 turtle species, helping you make an informed and responsible choice.

Before You Dive In: Key Turtle Care Considerations

Before you fall in love with a tiny turtle hatchling, it's crucial to understand the realities of their care. Getting the setup right from day one is the key to a healthy, happy pet.

A Lifelong Commitment

This isn't an exaggeration. Many of the turtles on our list live for 20 to 50 years, and some can live even longer. A pet turtle is a companion you may have for a significant portion of your life. You'll need to consider who would care for the turtle if you move, go to college, or can no longer look after it. This long lifespan is one of the biggest responsibilities in turtle ownership.

The Right Environment is Non-Negotiable

Most pet turtles are aquatic or semi-aquatic and require a significant water setup. A tiny plastic container with a palm tree won't cut it. You'll need a large aquarium—often 75 gallons or more for an adult—with a powerful filtration system. Turtles are messy, and maintaining water quality is a constant task to prevent shell rot, respiratory infections, and other serious health issues.

Every aquatic turtle also needs a basking area where they can get completely dry and warm up under a heat lamp. Crucially, they require a special UVB light to help them metabolize calcium and grow a healthy shell. Without proper heating and UVB, your turtle will become very sick. We highly recommend checking out a guide to the Best Heat Lamps For Reptiles Comparison to understand your options.

Diet: More Than Just Lettuce

While some land turtles enjoy leafy greens, the dietary needs of aquatic turtles are more complex. Most are omnivores, requiring a balanced diet of commercial turtle pellets, leafy greens (like romaine or dandelion greens), and occasional protein like shrimp or worms. Researching your specific species' diet is essential for their long-term health.

The 4-Inch Law and Salmonella Safety

In the U.S., it's illegal to sell turtles with a shell length of less than four inches. This law was enacted in the 1970s to prevent the spread of Salmonella, particularly to children who were more likely to put small turtles in their mouths. All reptiles can carry Salmonella, and it's vital to wash your hands thoroughly after handling your turtle or its habitat. Because of this risk, turtles are not ideal pets for very young children or immunocompromised individuals.

The 10 Best Pet Turtles for Every Keeper

Now that you understand the basics, let's explore some of the best pet turtles to have. We've ranked them based on a combination of size, temperament, and overall care difficulty.

1. Common Musk Turtle (Stinkpot)

Quick Facts:

• Size: 3-5 inches
• Lifespan: 30-50 years
• Difficulty: Beginner

The Common Musk Turtle, affectionately known as the "Stinkpot," is at the top of our list for good reason. Its small adult size makes it one of the most manageable aquatic turtles. They get their nickname from the musky odor they can release when frightened, but this rarely happens in captivity with a well-adjusted pet.

These turtles are primarily aquatic and spend most of their time walking along the bottom of the tank. They are not the strongest swimmers, so they appreciate plenty of decorations, driftwood, and plants to rest on. A 20-gallon long tank is often sufficient for a single adult, making them a great choice for keepers with limited space.

Stinkpots are carnivores, enjoying a diet of quality turtle pellets, bloodworms, and chopped earthworms. They can be a bit shy but often become quite personable, learning to recognize their owners and come for food.

2. Western Painted Turtle

Quick Facts:

• Size: 4-10 inches
• Lifespan: 25-30 years
• Difficulty: Beginner to Intermediate

The Western Painted Turtle is one of North America's most beautiful and recognizable turtles. Their dark shells are ringed with intricate red and yellow patterns, and their skin is covered in bright yellow stripes. They are active, curious swimmers and provide endless entertainment as they explore their aquatic home.

As a medium-sized turtle, a single adult needs at least a 75-gallon aquarium to provide adequate swimming space. They are enthusiastic baskers, so a stable dock under a quality UVB and heat lamp is a must. Their diet is omnivorous; you should offer a mix of commercial pellets, leafy greens, and occasional insects.

Painted Turtles are generally hardy and adapt well to captivity. While they can be skittish and may retreat into the water when you approach, they typically have a calm demeanor and are a joy to watch.

3. Reeve's Turtle

Quick Facts:

• Size: 4-6 inches
• Lifespan: 20+ years
• Difficulty: Beginner

Reeve's Turtles are a fantastic choice for those looking for a smaller species with a big personality. Originating from Asia, these semi-aquatic turtles are known for being quite personable and less shy than many other species. They often become tame enough to accept food directly from their owner's hand.

Their smaller size means they can be comfortably housed in a 30 to 40-gallon aquarium. They are omnivores and are not picky eaters, readily accepting pellets, greens, and protein. One of their defining features is their shell, which has three distinct keels (ridges) running down its length.

The Reeve's Turtle's manageable size and friendly disposition make it one of the best pet turtles to have, especially for those new to the hobby who want a more interactive pet.

4. African Sideneck Turtle

Quick Facts:

• Size: 7-12 inches
• Lifespan: 25-50 years
• Difficulty: Beginner to Intermediate

Instantly recognizable by how they tuck their head to the side instead of straight back, African Sideneck Turtles are unique and fascinating pets. They have a comical, friendly-looking "smile" that endears them to many keepers.

These are highly aquatic turtles that require a large tank, at least 75 gallons for an adult, with a powerful canister filter. They are omnivores with a preference for protein, so their diet should consist of pellets, worms, and shrimp, with occasional greens. Unlike many other turtles, they often eat their food in the water.

African Sidenecks are generally social and can sometimes be housed together, but you must watch carefully for any signs of aggression. Their unique appearance and active nature make them a captivating addition to a home aquarium.

5. Mississippi Map Turtle

Quick Facts:

• Size: 5-10 inches (females are much larger)
• Lifespan: 20-30 years
• Difficulty: Intermediate

Map Turtles get their name from the intricate, map-like lines on their shells. The Mississippi Map Turtle is a popular species known for the fin-like ridge running down its back and the crescent-shaped markings behind its eyes. They are extremely active swimmers and love to bask.

Their primary challenge is their sensitivity to water quality. You'll need excellent filtration and perform regular water changes to keep them healthy, as they are prone to shell and skin infections in poor conditions. A 75-gallon tank is a minimum for an adult female.

They are quite timid and will leap into the water at the slightest disturbance, so they are a pet for observation rather than handling. Their diet consists mainly of pellets and insects, with females developing powerful jaws to eat snails and crustaceans.

6. Spotted Turtle

Quick Facts:

• Size: 3-5 inches
• Lifespan: 30-50+ years
• Difficulty: Intermediate to Advanced

The Spotted Turtle is a tiny, beautiful species with a smooth black shell covered in bright yellow spots. Their small size is a major draw, but they are not for beginners. They are a protected species in many areas, so you must ensure you are buying a captive-bred specimen from a reputable breeder.

They require a semi-aquatic setup with shallow, clean water and a significant land area with substrate they can burrow into. A 20 or 30-gallon long tank can work well. Spotted Turtles are very sensitive to water quality and temperature, making their care more demanding than that of a Stinkpot or Reeve's Turtle.

These turtles are shy and do not tolerate handling well. They are best for experienced keepers who can provide the specific environment they need to thrive and appreciate their beauty from a distance.

7. Eastern Box Turtle

Quick Facts:

• Size: 4-6 inches
• Lifespan: 40-100 years
• Difficulty: Intermediate

If an aquatic setup seems too daunting, an Eastern Box Turtle might be for you. These are terrestrial turtles that live on land. They have a high-domed shell with beautiful yellow and orange markings. Their most famous feature is a hinged plastron (bottom shell) that allows them to close up completely—hence the name "box turtle."

Box turtles do not swim well and should never be housed in an aquarium. They need a large, custom-built outdoor enclosure or a spacious indoor "turtle table." The enclosure must have deep, moist substrate for burrowing, a water dish for soaking, and hiding spots. Their lifespan is incredibly long, often exceeding 50 years, making them a true lifetime commitment.

They are omnivores, eating a varied diet of earthworms, slugs, fruits, and vegetables. Box turtles can become very personable and recognize their owners, but they can be easily stressed by overhandling.

8. Yellow-Bellied Slider

Quick Facts:

• Size: 8-13 inches (females are larger)
• Lifespan: 30-40 years
• Difficulty: Beginner to Intermediate

Closely related to the Red-Eared Slider, the Yellow-Bellied Slider is a common and popular pet. They are active, love to bask, and have a generally friendly and curious nature. Their bright yellow plastron gives them their name.

Like their cousins, the biggest consideration is their adult size. That adorable little hatchling will grow into a large, powerful turtle that requires a very large tank—think 100 gallons or more. This is a significant investment in space, equipment, and cost. If you can provide the space, they are hardy and rewarding pets.

Their care is otherwise straightforward. They are omnivores that thrive on a diet of pellets and fresh greens. They are some of the best pet turtles to have if you have the space to accommodate their adult size.

9. Red-Eared Slider

Quick Facts:

• Size: 8-13 inches
• Lifespan: 20-40 years
• Difficulty: Intermediate

No list of pet turtles would be complete without the Red-Eared Slider. For decades, they were the pet turtle. Unfortunately, their widespread availability led to many impulse purchases by owners unprepared for their adult size and needs. As a result, they are one of the most abandoned pets and have become an invasive species worldwide.

We include them here with a strong caution: only get a Red-Eared Slider if you are fully prepared for a 12-inch turtle that needs a 100+ gallon setup for 30+ years. They are hardy, active, and can become quite tame. Their care is identical to the Yellow-Bellied Slider. If you can meet their needs, they can be wonderful pets. Consider adopting one from a reptile rescue, as many are in need of good homes.

10. Southern Painted Turtle

Quick Facts:

• Size: 4-6 inches
• Lifespan: 25-30 years
• Difficulty: Beginner

For those who love the look of the Painted Turtle but lack the space for a larger species, the Southern Painted Turtle is a perfect alternative. They are the smallest of the painted turtle subspecies, typically staying under 6 inches. They are identifiable by a prominent red or orange stripe running down the center of their shell.

Their care is very similar to the Western Painted Turtle, but their smaller size means a 40-gallon tank can comfortably house an adult for life. They are active swimmers and baskers with a curious and hardy nature.

This species combines the beauty of painted turtles with a manageable size, making it one of the best pet turtles to have for keepers who want a classic turtle experience without requiring a massive enclosure.

Your New Shelled Companion

Turtles are truly special pets that offer a unique window into the natural world. From the small, bottom-dwelling Musk Turtle to the large and active sliders, there is a turtle out there for every dedicated keeper. The most important step is to do your research and be honest about the time, space, and financial resources you can provide.

A turtle is a long-term friend, not a temporary hobby. If you're ready for the commitment, you'll be rewarded with a fascinating companion for years to come. And if you decide a turtle's needs are too demanding, remember there are many other amazing reptiles to consider, from lizards to snakes. In fact, you might find that one of the Best Pet Snakes for Beginners: 10 Top Picks Ranked is a better fit for your lifestyle.